The Benefit of Working Together

For the last week, I’ve been taking part in a teaching workshop.  During that time, we were asked to share and edit each other’s work.  It’s not easy, handing your work over to a peer to look at and give comments on.  On the flip side, it’s not easy to make constructive comments about the work of your peers.  While it’s not easy from any angle, working with my peers to edit and improve my work.

It got me to thinking.

In digital scrapbooking, how often do we work together as peers to improve our work?  Sure, in paper scrapbooking we can go to crops and sit and scrapbook with others and ask their opinion, but in digital scrapbooking, is that really possible?  Sure, we have chat rooms and forums…but it’s not easy for us to get together and share our work in real-time.

Does it really matter?

I’m not totally sure.  I mean, yes, we can work on our scrapbooking layouts on our own and never ask any of our peers for their opinion or assistance.  I would argue, though, that we are doing ourselves a disservice.  While it may be hard to do, and we may not always feel comfortable, getting the opinion of the people around us almost always helps us improve our work.  In the training, we were asked to write paragraphs evaluating a teaching experience.  I consider myself a good writer, and was comfortable with the product I had in front of me.  However, after talking about the piece with another peer, I had many different ideas to add to the product, or to make improvements on.  The bottom line is this…after having my peer edit my work, my work was better.  Could this also work with our scrapbooking layouts?

You bet it can.

In fact, I ask for opinions and help all the time.  In my digi life, I have a trusted friend and peer that I always turn to for opinions on my work.  In fact, we often ask each other opinions about our layouts.  What does that look like?  It’s not what you think.  I don’t “turn in” my layout and have my friend give me a written critique about it.  More often than not, it’s us talking on Yahoo Messenger, sharing screenshots of our work.  We ask questions like “Which paper looks better?” or “What’s missing from this layout?”  Almost 100% of the time, I take the advice I am given and I am always happier with how the layout turns out.  Could I have made a layout that I was happy with on my own?  Sure.  The layout that I end up with after working with my friend I always like better.

Do you ask for help when you are creating your layouts?  If so, how do you go about doing it?  If not, what’s holding you back?

This entry was posted in Scrapping Tips and Techniques. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to The Benefit of Working Together

  1. Amanda Frazier says:

    I know it sounds really weird, but along with family members and friends, I often ask my son. Lots of my layouts are about him and even though he’s only 4 years old, he has his opinions and a lot of times they’re good ones. Sometimes I get so caught up in making a layout look “good” or ready in time for that deadline that I miss what memory I’m trying to capture. If he can’t tell me what’s going on in the pictures because of all the other stuff on the layout (whether it’s just badly done or completely irrelevant), chances are I’ve missed the mark. 🙂

  2. Melissa says:

    I get my DH to help me sometimes. I’m building a group of Perth Scrapbookers over on my site- the most so far at a workshop has been 3 🙂 but we’ll grow!

  3. Butterflyflutterby says:

    coming from the PSP world to scrapping this is the norm for me  its less so over the years in the very beginning we all shared in our groups comments suggestions …. unfortunately its seems to be happening less and less  i show 2-3 close friends ive had for several years my work and trust there honest feedback ,,,,, to many times no very few tutorials share the full skills knowledge to the few that do openly in tutorials and opinions are greatly appreciated how anyone is meant to learn any-more when so few share there wisdom …..   

     thankfully you are one of many few and appreciated 

  4. Georgia Whalen says:

    You make a good point! I have asked for help by emailing 2 versions of the same page to a friend to get her opinion.  But of course, it doesn’t happen as often as when I am paper scrapbooking at a crop.  We have been discussing having digi-crops and bringing our laptops to work together. 

  5. Rebecca (ReboScraps) says:

    Yes, yes, yes!!! My best friend (and the guilty party who got me hooked on digital scrapbooking!) and I live 1500 miles apart, but we email our in-progress layouts to each other quite often for feedback. This definitely makes our pages better! We have also been known to attend the same speed scraps, with our own chat going via gmail. So fun!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s